Skip to main content

Posts

Showing posts with the label Sherlock Holmes

The Great Debate: Clashing Over Fictional MBTI Types

The Great Debate: Clashing Over Fictional MBTI Types Typing fictional characters with the Myers-Briggs Type Indicator (MBTI) is one of the most popular—and contentious—hobbies in the personality community. It's a fantastic way to breathe life into the 16 types , but it sparks lively debates. While some characters showcase clear preferences, others are complex, leaving room for interpretation. These debates are so passionate because characters are often written inconsistently, or they grow and change. An author isn't usually thinking of cognitive functions , so a character might show traits of two different types. Let's explore some of the most iconic clashes. For a deeper look at the types, check out the MBTI Guide book . Sherlock Holmes (INTJ vs. ISTJ) This is the classic Intuition vs. Sensing debate. The INTJ Argument: Sherlock 's brilliance isn't just observation; it's deduction . He uses Introverted Intuition (Ni) to see a "big pictu...